Josh Kerr Says Water Not Needed for Runs Under 12

Josh Kerr, the Scottish middle-distance runner who holds the mile world record, suggests that recreational runners often carry too much gear. During a Reddit AMA hosted by BBC Sport, the Olympic champion and 1500-meter world champion stated that athletes do not need water bottles for runs shorter than 12 miles. He noted that runners in cities can stop at a store if they require fluids during their workout.
The Equipment Debate
The runner explained that he has worn a hydration vest only once and found the experience unpleasant. He described the two bottles bouncing against the chest and leaking down the shirt, creating a constant sloshing sound. The discomfort was not limited to the gear itself; he spent significant time adjusting the vest during the run, which detracted from the experience.
Runner @natalie.the.capn shared Kerr’s comments on Threads, countering the advice with her own experience. She explained that she wears a hydration belt on every outing to secure her phone, a safety necessity often overlooked by male runners. She also noted that some of her routes span six miles or more between places where she can find water, making the gear essential for her routine.
This distinction highlights how running conditions vary widely. Kerr competes at the highest level, logging miles that differ significantly from those of recreational athletes. His perspective on equipment is informed by professional training, but the practical needs of different runners depend on factors like environment, pace, and individual safety concerns.
Many social media users agreed with Kerr. One commenter replied, “Yeah im gonna listen to the guy who runs for a living but thanks,” while others pointed out that beginners, slower runners, and those training in hot weather have different hydration requirements. Kerr acknowledged that people carry gear for various reasons, a detail often lost in the debate over his comments.
For those training for marathons, the advice changes. A writer who has completed marathon training four times noted that longer distances require water to wash down energy gels and prevent dehydration. Stopping to buy a drink or pause a watch midway through a long run can also disrupt the rhythm of a training session, making specialized gear more practical for those specific workouts.
